The Wrong Gods by S. Shakthidharan. Belvoir Theatre co-produced with Melbourne Theatre Company, at Belvoir Theatre, Sydney, May 3 – June 1, 2025.
Supported by The Hive – Supporting emerging talent at Belvoir
Reviewed by Frank McKone
May 11
CAST
Nirmala: Nadie Kammallaweera Isha: Radhika Mudaliyar
Devi: Manali Datar Lakshmi: Vaishnavi Suryaprakesh
CREATIVES
Writer and Co-Director: S. Shakthidharan
Co-Director: Hannah Goodwin
Set and Costume Designer: Keerthi Subramanyam
Lighting Designer: Amelia Lever-Davidson
Sound Designer: Steve Francis
Associate Sound Designer: Madeleine Picard
Composer: Sabyasachi (Rahul) Bhattacharya
Tabla performed by Aman Pal
Indian soundscapes recorded by George Vlad (mindful-audio.com)
Movement & Fight Director, Intimacy Coordinator: Nigel Poulton
Vocal Coach: Laura Farrell
Stage Manager: Madelaine Osborn; Stage Manager: Steph Storr
Assistant Stage Manager: Mia Kanzaki; Assistant Stage Manager:
Grace Sackman
Digital Program at https://belvoir.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/TWG-Digital-Program_v5.pdf
Cover photography by Daniel Boud
Rehearsal photography by Brett Boardman
![]() | |
The four women at a light moment in rehearsal as Isha, Nirmala, Devi and Lakshmi The Wrong Gods by S. Shakthidharan, Belvoir 2025 |
We
are putting our faith in the wrong ideas. The wrong systems. The wrong
gods. That woman, in the valley. Her gods and our gods are going to
need to talk to each other. They are going to have to work together. It
will take an openness on both sides. They are ready.
But are we?
This
is the ending of the Author/Director’s program note. It’s where we
begin to appreciate his play, written he says, because of his experience
more than a decade ago:
She's sitting on the banks of her
river, deep in her valley, in the remote heart of India. She's staring
at me. I'm brushing off her soil from my lenses, my tripod, my cables.
I've just finished an interview with her. As I head back up the
mountain, to where my Australian arts colleagues are waiting, she yells:
'make sure you get our story onto that TV!' It's not a request: it's an
order. Her cow bellows his [her?] support. 'I'll try, aunty,' I feebly
call back down the mountain.
Not on television, but powerfully on real-life stage, The Wrong Gods makes its point in a straightforward manner, in 90 minutes, no interval.
That
woman in the valley, with her cow but no man left to work, is Nirmala, a
traditional small farmer, needing her teenage daughter to leave school
to keep the farm going. Isha has been told by her teacher, Devi, that
she is very bright. Isha insists on going on to school in the city.
Both
mother and daughter are very determined characters. Though Nirmala is
afraid of ‘modern’ influences, after a highly emotional argument, she
finally gives in and lets Isha go.
But soon Lakshmi appears, a
modern executive, in a program to explain to the villagers how her
American company is being funded, including by the Indian government, to
dam the valley to supply clean water to the millions living in the
city. This will drown 40,000 people's homes. In the theatre world,
there are echoes here going right back to Henrik Ibsen and An Enemy of the People.
On
the side, I had a picture in mind of the town of Adaminaby, drowned in
the building of the 1940s-50s Snowy Mountains water supply scheme in
Kosciuszko National Park, not far from Canberra, Australia, where I
live.
When Isha returns she is educated in science and sees the
necessity of modern development, the new Indian god, while her mother
refuses to leave and would rather drown than deny the traditional gods
and thousands of years of her indigenous way of life.
I thought
then of the sincere acknowledgement of the Gadigal Eora people, original
custodians of the land where Belvoir stands, given by Radhika
Mudaliyar just before moving into the role of Isha at the opening of the
play. In the end, as Isha, she reconciles with her mother Nirmala –
but as S. Shakthidharan says, are we ready?
And then I thought –
in 200 years modern progress has already brought us far worse than the
damming of many valleys like Nirmala’s. Even if we can limit the CO2 in
the atmosphere with our net-zero plan by 2050, we are already past
tipping-points according to most scientists – like Isha becomes in the
play. Can we ever be ready for a world-wide future so inhospitable as
to be incapable of supporting human life?
The Wrong Gods pulls no punches.
![]() |
Isha and her mother Nirmala in rehearsal reacting to the inevitability of modern 'progress' as Lakshmi and Devi explain. The Wrong Gods by S. Shakthidharan, Belvoir 2025 |
Copyright: Frank McKone, Canberra